Claims and Payments Berkshire Hathaway Guard Claims: 888-639-2567 Payments: 800-673-2465 Nationwide Claims: 800-421-3535 Payments: 888-891-0867 Mutual of Enumclaw Insurance Claims: 877-425-2580 Payments: 800-456-7750 Zurich Claims: 800-987-3373 Payments: 800-332-6641 Safeco Insurance Claims: 800-332-3226 Payments: 888-726-3260 Progressive Claims 800-776-4737 Payments 800-888-7764 Liberty Mutual Claims: 844-629-8984 Payments: 800-290-8102 CNA Surety Claims: 877-672-6115 Payments: 800-331-6053 Oregon Mutual Claims: 800-934-3809 Payments: 800-409-3814